From the journal

Replacing a shipping guarantee with programmable trade finance payments

Keep the existing guarantee until its beneficiary has accepted either verified payment of the protected exposure or an effective replacement undertaking. A funded reservation in the carrier's bank account becomes a credible substitute only when the agent has enforceable rights to payment on terms covering the money it will advance. The Panama Canal Authority (ACP) must separately receive advance payment or accept the required bank security. A release to the agent after transit cannot itself satisfy that earlier requirement.

15 min read

This article addresses an English-law agreement under which a shipping agent advances transit charges for a carrier. The carrier proposes reserving funds in its own bank account and releasing them after an agreed port event. The acceptance steps below assume a commercial vessel using an authorised agent; the actual vessel dimensions, booking programme, bank entity and signed instruments determine the final requirements.

Identify both debts before changing the security

The agency agreement should identify the carrier's reimbursement obligation, the agent's fees, payment dates and responsibility for additional charges. That contractual debt is distinct from the payment obligations owed to ACP. Under article 10 of ACP's Navigation Regulation, creating a visit and requesting services commits the authorised agent to payment for requested services received and unrequested services provided for causes not attributable to ACP. The agent must arrange timely payment or a bank guarantee. Other Canal-user obligations can coexist with that agent obligation. Acuerdo 360 of 12 December 2019, articles 9–10, official Register pp11–12.

  • Carrier to shipping agent. Agency reimbursement debt.
  • Shipping agent to ACP. Transit and service payment.
  • Account bank to carrier. Deposit debt.
  • Account bank to shipping agent. Proposed conditional payment.
  • Agent's guarantee issuer to shipping agent. Separate undertaking.
  • ACP-approved guarantor to ACP. Accepted Canal security.
  • Event provider or operator to account bank. Authenticated event evidence.

The roles may be performed by overlapping institutions. The documents must identify the legal person and branch performing each role.

  • Carrier's reimbursement and fee obligations. Creditor or beneficiary: Shipping agent. Evidence needed before the agent advances money: Signed agency agreement, approved disbursement estimate and allocation of later charges.
  • Agent's payment obligations for Canal services. Creditor or beneficiary: ACP. Evidence needed before the agent advances money: Relevant visit and service requests, current estimate, accepted payment or guarantee, and financial clearance.
  • Carrier's ordinary bank deposit. Creditor or beneficiary: Carrier as account holder. Evidence needed before the agent advances money: Account terms, bank entity and branch, reservation terms and authority to instruct transfers.
  • Existing or replacement guarantee protecting the agent. Creditor or beneficiary: The beneficiary named in that instrument. Evidence needed before the agent advances money: Complete issued instrument, amendments, cap, demands, expiry and release provisions.
  • Bank security securing Canal charges. Creditor or beneficiary: ACP under its accepted arrangement. Evidence needed before the agent advances money: Particular bank undertaking and ACP acceptance covering the visit and charges.
  • Event reporting and payment operation. Creditor or beneficiary: Contractual recipients of the operator's services. Evidence needed before the agent advances money: Evidence specification, service terms, access to records and a fallback presentation route.

The first task is therefore to read the old guarantee. If it names the agent, release requires reconciliation of the agent's reimbursement and fee exposure alongside ACP clearance. If it names ACP, the agent cannot release it on ACP's behalf. The carrier should request the appropriate beneficiary's release only after the protected obligations and replacement conditions have been reconciled.

Direct payment to ACP can eliminate the need for an agent to advance the covered amount. The agency agreement and the agent's reconciliation must also establish how that payment affects any existing reimbursement debt, fees and residual charges. The same separation between payment evidence and discharge is developed in Licentium's analysis of stablecoin payments for cross-border supplier invoices.

What Citi's announcements establish

On 10 October 2024, Citi reported real transit-payment pilots with CB Fenton and GAC Panama Shipping. The same announcement separately described Citi Token Services for Cash moving into commercial operation. Those statements establish the reported engagements and their stated status. A proposed carrier arrangement requires its own bank undertaking, account terms and ACP acceptance. Citi's October 2024 announcement.

Subsequent public descriptions require care. A 23 September 2025 Citi article described Cash and Trade as launched, while its digital-assets page, as at 18 November 2026, still described Trade as being in pilot mode. Citi's 28 September 2026 expansion announcement concerned payment and liquidity capabilities in Japan and the United Arab Emirates. The relationship manager should confirm current availability of the particular Panama trade arrangement in writing for the proposed bank entity, corridor, currency and customer. Citi's 2025 description; digital-assets page; September 2026 expansion.

As at 18 November 2026, Citi's product page describes service features. The acceptance decision still requires the actual bank promise and applicable account terms. ACP's acceptance of the particular reservation as transit security requires separate confirmation.

Determine what the bank actually promises

For a bank undertaking governed by English law, an independent demand guarantee creates a payment obligation triggered by a complying demand under its terms. A secondary guarantee answers for the principal debtor's failure to perform the secured obligation. Proof of that liability may be necessary, but a prior judgment or arbitral award is required only if the instrument makes it a condition. On the summary-judgment application in CE Energy DMCC v Bashar, the court accepted a realistic prospect of a suretyship construction while rejecting an asserted requirement for prior adjudication. The instrument's complete wording and commercial context controlled its construction. CE Energy DMCC v Bashar [2025] EWHC 297 (Comm), paragraphs 35–48.

A condition linked to transit can also trigger an independent bank obligation. Independence concerns whether the bank's liability depends on the underlying carrier debt; the event condition identifies when the bank must pay. The agent should ask whether the bank promises payment to it directly when the specified evidence arrives, or merely agrees to operate the carrier's payment instruction. The distinction between an independent conditional obligation and secondary suretyship is recognised in Havila Kystruten AS v Abarca Companhia De Seguros SA [2022] EWHC 3196 (Comm), paragraphs 384–397.

Apply Shanghai Shipyard within its wording

The Court of Appeal's 23 July 2021 decision in Shanghai Shipyard v Reignwood resolved two preliminary construction issues concerning a non-bank company's guarantee of a US$170 million final shipbuilding instalment. Its combination of immediate demand-payment language, protections against underlying disputes and a particular arbitration clause supported the court's demand-guarantee construction. Under that clause, the dispute had to have been submitted to arbitration before the valid demand; later arbitration did not suspend the accrued immediate payment obligation. Shanghai Shipyard Co Ltd v Reignwood International Investment (Group) Co Ltd [2021] EWCA Civ 1147, paragraphs 8, 32–38 and 52–60, archived official judgment.

That reasoning directs attention to the whole undertaking, including the point when the bank's obligation accrues and the precise effect of a dispute. Insolvency treatment requires the separate rights and applicable-law analysis below. Documentary control over a shipping record addresses a different legal function, explored in Licentium's electronic bills of lading and bank collateral analysis.

Under English law, an ordinary deposit creates a debt owed by the bank to its account holder. An agent's proprietary interest, security over the deposit claim or direct bank claim requires the relevant legal terms and applicable-law analysis. A balance confirmation should identify the funded amount, but the agent also needs the operative undertaking and restrictions on withdrawal, revocation, amendment and set-off. Philipp v Barclays Bank UK PLC [2023] UKSC 25, paragraphs 26–30.

Compare the three acceptance routes

  • Agent's protection. Independent guarantee: Direct claim against the issuer under the instrument. Confirmed prepayment: Money received and allocated before the agent advances, or ACP paid directly for the covered amount. Conditional bank reservation: Depends on a binding bank promise, security or other enforceable rights in the signed terms.
  • Payment trigger. Independent guarantee: Complying demand and stipulated documents within time. Confirmed prepayment: Actual credited, available payment confirmed by the recipient. Conditional bank reservation: Defined event and evidence that the signed undertaking recognises as the payment trigger.
  • Underlying dispute. Independent guarantee: Usually separated from the issuer's obligation, subject to the instrument, restrictions on calling and applicable law. Confirmed prepayment: Remaining disputes concern allocation, adjustment or repayment under the agreement. Conditional bank reservation: May delay payment if the terms permit; an independent undertaking can limit this effect.
  • Transit never occurs after costs arise. Independent guarantee: Covered only if the guaranteed obligations and valid demand route extend to those costs. Confirmed prepayment: Reconcile the prepaid amount, charges and any refund. Conditional bank reservation: Successful-transit release alone leaves this exposure uncovered; add an alternative trigger or separate security.
  • Carrier becomes insolvent. Independent guarantee: Agent looks to the issuer, subject to the undertaking and applicable law. Confirmed prepayment: Covered advance is already funded; further recovery or avoidance issues depend on the facts and law. Conditional bank reservation: A bare earmark may leave the deposit claim with the carrier's estate and the agent claiming against the carrier.
  • Bank becomes insolvent. Independent guarantee: Agent has its claim against the issuer; recovery depends on the applicable resolution and insolvency regime. Confirmed prepayment: Assess the recipient's bank exposure after receipt. Conditional bank reservation: Identify who has a deposit, direct undertaking or proprietary claim and establish its priority under the applicable regime.
  • ACP requirement. Independent guarantee: Satisfied only by security accepted by ACP for its own charges. Confirmed prepayment: Satisfied when ACP receives the required amount through an accepted route. Conditional bank reservation: Requires ACP's specific acceptance as security, or separate advance payment or accepted security.

The guarantee and deposit starting points follow the authorities above. The reservation entries identify the contractual evidence needed to classify the proposed arrangement. Even a fully funded mechanism can leave the agent exposed if it pays only after successful transit while the agent incurs costs earlier.

Match URDG 758 to the intended payment event

The International Chamber of Commerce's Uniform Rules for Demand Guarantees (URDG 758) apply through express incorporation, subject to the instrument's modifications. Article 2 defines a demand as a signed beneficiary document requesting payment. Specify how an automated process produces and delivers that demand. Under article 7, an event condition needs specified documentary evidence or an applicable route through the guarantor's own records of account credits or debits or an index specified in the guarantee; otherwise the guarantor disregards the condition, subject to checking stipulated documents for conflicting data. Check articles 14–15, 19–20 and 25 for presentation, supporting documents, examination and expiry. Articles 34–35 separately address the guarantee's governing law and forum, which require their own determination.

Article 15(a) ordinarily requires a beneficiary statement identifying the applicant's breach; article 15(c) permits express exclusion. A successful-transit payment mechanism must expressly address that breach-statement requirement, or sit alongside a separate default guarantee. In TTSJV v BapCo, decided 4 August 2026, the court rejected an interim challenge after the applicant accepted that a supporting statement accompanied the demand; article 15(a) permits a separate signed statement. TTSJV W.L.L. v BapCo Refining B.S.C. [2026] EWHC 2047 (TCC), paragraphs 39–44.

The parties should approve a sample complying presentation before implementation. Specify the event issuer, vessel and visit identifiers, timestamp, permitted correction, presentation place and deadline, electronic format, delivery channel and authenticated manual fallback. Article 14 defaults to paper presentation if the guarantee specifies no medium. Record whether the bank examines documents or relies on an identified external record, and make the payment deadline explicit.

Meet ACP's advance-payment and security requirements

Article 77 of Panama's Organic Law, Law 19 of 11 June 1997, requires the Canal user to deposit the service cost before service and permits substitution by a bank guarantee satisfying ACP's requirements. Article 9 of the Toll Regulation requires payment before lock transit and payment of later qualifying charges before the vessel leaves Canal waters. Article 10 addresses approved banks and ACP-authorised payment mechanisms. The controlling Spanish sources are Law 19, article 77, p26 and Acuerdo 4 of 7 January 1999, articles 9–12, p3.

A bank-funded transfer can therefore satisfy the payment route when ACP receives and allocates the required amount through an accepted mechanism. Acceptance of security requires the particular ACP-approved arrangement. The agent should obtain the relevant financial-clearance record and match it to the vessel visit, services, currency and amount. Operational transit permission may also depend on separate navigation and booking requirements.

The applicable timing has several layers:

  • General processing: N-3-2026, effective 1 January 2026, §6(c), says vessels should coordinate and process payment or guarantees at least 48 hours before the service date, including contingency coverage. This is an operational lead time alongside the legal advance-payment requirement. The same notice requires the agent's guarantor-bank letter and ACP evaluation and approval. N-3-2026, §§5(b)(6) and 6(c), printed pp12 and 15.
  • Booking programme: As at 18 November 2026, LoTSA 2.5 terms require slot payment or a bank guarantee 96 hours before transit for that programme. Its period runs from 5 July 2026 to 2 January 2027. The programme must be identified before fixing the transaction's deadline. LoTSA 2.5, §I.1.3, p2.
  • Vessel route: N-3-2026 also addresses vessels up to 38.1 metres or 125 feet without an authorised agent through a separate process. The agent must confirm the vessel classification, agency route, booking programme and current instructions.

ACP's forms also need their correct function. The agent application, Form 3676, version 17 September 2026, records agency and payment commitments. The active sheet of Form 4623, version 1 January 2025, records booking authority and fee acceptance; Form 4633, version 27 October 2024, deals with cancellation, substitution and date-change charges. Obtain the bank's complete accepted guarantee separately. Booking cancellation leaves applicable accrued charges to be settled. ACP Customer Forms.

Test release, disputed records and failure

The following are acceptance terms to agree before funds are advanced. Their legal effect depends on the signed instruments and applicable law.

  • Valid transit is confirmed. Evidence and response to specify: Named event record, matching visit identifiers and bank acknowledgement; confirm net credit to the intended recipient. Exposure to cover: Distinguish a release instruction from receipt and allocation of money.
  • Event records conflict. Evidence and response to specify: Order of priority between records, correction authority, notice method, fixed challenge deadline and decision-maker. Exposure to cover: Pay the undisputed amount where agreed; preserve the disputed amount without an indefinite carrier veto.
  • Transit is cancelled or never occurs. Evidence and response to specify: Documents showing advances and chargeable services; reimbursement/default trigger or separate guarantee. Exposure to cover: Charges incurred before the successful event, including applicable cancellation and extra-service charges.
  • Operator fails while the bank can pay. Evidence and response to specify: Direct authenticated presentation to the bank and access to event records outside the failed system. Exposure to cover: Bank payment duty should survive loss of the operator and should not depend on unnecessary further carrier consent.
  • Carrier fails while funds remain reserved. Evidence and response to specify: Account ownership, agent's direct bank undertaking and any valid security or trust documentation. Exposure to cover: Determine whether the agent claims against the carrier, bank or identified property; obtain the relevant insolvency analysis.
  • Account bank or guarantee issuer fails. Evidence and response to specify: Exact legal entity, branch, instrument, account location and governing resolution regime. Exposure to cover: Establish any segregation, priority and recovery rights under the applicable regime.

Write the dispute override expressly: who can stop payment, on what documents, for which amount and until when. Include a method for an agreed decision or binding order to resolve the hold. Mandatory orders and applicable law remain relevant. An ordinary underlying dispute does not by itself establish a right to restrain an independent bond call; express restrictions on the beneficiary's call require separate attention. TTSJV, paragraphs 25–26.

Keep the reservation expiry, last guarantee-demand date and payment deadline distinct. A dispute notice or a continuing software lock does not itself extend a guarantee. Arrange an express extension where needed, or present a valid demand within the existing terms. Return unused funds only after agreed reconciliation of paid amounts, remaining charges and timely claims; identify the person entitled to the return and who can authorise it.

The acceptance schedule

Complete this schedule in the signed transaction documents. Enter actual dates, times and time zones after confirming the transit and charge timetable.

  • Beneficiary and protected debt. Required entry and evidence: Agent's full legal name for its protection; ACP separately for Canal security; covered advances, fees, extras, cap and currency. Responsible party: Carrier and agent counsel, with each issuer.
  • Bank obligation and funding. Required entry and evidence: Issuer and account-bank entities and branches; signed direct undertaking or bank agreement; funded balance, control, amendment, revocation and set-off terms. Responsible party: Authorised bank signatory; agent's finance and counsel.
  • Documentary trigger. Required entry and evidence: Approved event record and sample presentation; separate route for unreimbursed advances when transit fails. Responsible party: Bank, agent and event provider.
  • Last demand date. Required entry and evidence: Exact expiry, presentation address or system, time zone, alternative channel, extension mechanism and payment period. Responsible party: Issuer and beneficiary.
  • Dispute override. Required entry and evidence: Challenge deadline, evidence hierarchy, limited hold, decision-maker, manual fallback and effect of a binding order. Responsible party: Carrier, agent and bank.
  • Canal requirements. Required entry and evidence: Applicable vessel and programme, payment deadline, accepted bank/undertaking, net funds or security coverage, and visit-specific financial clearance. Responsible party: Agent obtains confirmation from ACP through its prescribed process; bank confirms its own undertaking.
  • Unused funds and old security. Required entry and evidence: Reconciliation, residual claims, return instructions, effective replacement and release by the old instrument's beneficiary. Responsible party: Agent finance, carrier and relevant beneficiary/issuer.

For the carrier, verified prepayment can remove the need for security over the amount already paid, once the beneficiary confirms the allocation and residual exposure. For the agent, retain the existing guarantee while a post-transit reservation offers only a carrier instruction or leaves advanced charges uncovered. A binding bank acknowledgement plus separate security can support the new workflow where the acknowledgement controls the reservation and the separate undertaking covers the remaining reimbursement and failure exposure.

A conditional bank undertaking may itself provide adequate replacement protection if its enforceable scope, evidence conditions and duration cover the whole exposure. In every route, obtain ACP's separate payment or security confirmation and the existing beneficiary's documented acceptance before releasing the old guarantee.

Planning a launch somewhere new?

Prefer email? Write to hello@licentium.io. By sending, you accept our privacy policy.