The available routes differ substantially. Hong Kong provides an express approval framework for shared books with eligible affiliated overseas platforms. The European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) rejects the described structure in which a platform under the Markets in Crypto-Assets Regulation (MiCA) merges its book with an unauthorised overseas co-operator. Canadian decisions demonstrate individually approved access to global books. Other jurisdictions require the group to fit its design within activity-specific permissions, custody rules and foreign-exchange controls. SFC circular 25EC56, paragraphs 5–26; ESMA Q&A 2579; Coinbase decision of 1 April 2026.
This comparison addresses spot crypto trading as at 18 November 2026. Tokenised securities, derivatives, financing and payment use create additional branches where identified below. The practical decision is which functions the group can combine, which must remain locally controlled, and which exposures require separate assets or contractual recourse.
Choose the operating model before comparing permissions
A crypto exchange shared order book brings orders from customers of several platforms into a common matching process. The legal assessment turns on who sets admission and matching rules, operates the system, controls execution and assumes the resulting obligations. A local entity can remain the customer’s contractual counterparty while a foreign affiliate performs a separately regulated activity.
Four structures should be documented separately.
- Joint shared book. What the arrangement does: Participating platforms combine orders in a jointly operated market. Principal legal question: Which entities operate the venue and what permits the cross-border combination?
- Affiliate venue access. What the arrangement does: The local firm participates in an affiliate’s venue. Principal legal question: Does it act as customer agent, principal or venue operator, and may that foreign venue serve it?
- External order routing. What the arrangement does: The local firm sends orders to a separate execution destination. Principal legal question: Which execution, transmission, venue-selection and custody duties remain local?
- Broker access. What the arrangement does: An intermediary accesses a venue for its clients, potentially through an omnibus account. Principal legal question: What claim does the customer hold against the broker, and who controls settlement assets?
An unrelated liquidity provider may quote directly to the local firm, trade as a participant, or provide bilateral request-for-quote execution. Those arrangements change both the permission analysis and the customer’s counterparty. They should be described according to the actual trading and asset flows. ESMA’s broker-model opinion and Brazil’s separate liquidity-provider and market-maker provisions show why these distinctions matter. ESMA Opinion 1048, paragraphs 19–40; Resolution BCB 520, articles 38–39.
The first deliverable should therefore identify each legal entity, customer population, token class, matching function, wallet controller and settlement debtor. Analyse the law connected to each function and customer location. Each entity needs the permission required for its actual role.
Hong Kong provides a detailed affiliate route
The Hong Kong shared order book framework applies to a platform licensed by the Securities and Futures Commission (SFC) and a related overseas corporation. The overseas operator must hold the appropriate licence where it operates. Its jurisdiction must belong to the Financial Action Task Force (FATF) or a FATF-style regional body and effectively implement the specified regulatory standards. The SFC must give prior written approval. The local platform also remains responsible for admitting eligible assets and customers. Shared Order Book Terms, conditions 3–6 and 48.
This is a specific application route. An unrelated venue cannot qualify as the overseas joint operator merely because it is regulated or supplies substantial liquidity. The group must demonstrate the required corporate relationship, the foreign regulatory regime, actual supervisory access and compliance with the licence conditions. Retail access requires prominent explanation of overseas risks and an express customer election. Conditions 3–6, 40–46 and 48–50.
The framework separates customer matching from inter-platform settlement. Customers fully prefund orders. Automated checks prevent orders exceeding available balances, and matching creates binding transactions with real-time ledger entries. The participating operators and designated custodians must then deliver the relevant assets through delivery versus payment, with settlement at least daily and intraday controls that keep unsettled exposure within the approved limit. The legal basis for transfers and netting must work under applicable insolvency law. Conditions 8–15 and 19–27.
The interval between matching and settlement creates a funded responsibility for the local platform. It remains fully accountable to its customers and must compensate settlement-failure losses without undue delay, including mark-to-market losses. A segregated reserve held on trust at an authorised Hong Kong bank must satisfy the SFC-agreed methodology and be at least equal to the Unsettled Trade Limit. Separate insurance or compensation arrangements cover the relevant settlement assets, including assets in transit. These resources address distinct loss mechanisms. Circular, paragraphs 15–18; conditions 25–39.
The rulebook must make default consequences enforceable against each participant and designated custodian. It should address material settlement delay, termination, recovery of losses and reporting. The operator must immediately suspend matching of its clients’ orders with other orders on the shared book if it fails to maintain the required level of the reserve fund or compensation arrangement. A parent-company assurance should be assessed against those specific funding and enforceability requirements.
Surveillance must cover the combined book. The Hong Kong operator needs access to overseas-originator and order information, an accountable responsible officer or manager-in-charge, and records capable of reconstructing the trading lifecycle for seven years. Commercial confidentiality clauses must accommodate those duties. Conditions 28–50.
Broker access and affiliate market making have separate controls. The SFC’s February 2026 dealing circular requires intermediary assessments of execution, custody and default arrangements, disclosure and retail choice; the Hong Kong Monetary Authority’s (HKMA) May 2026 guidance addresses registered institutions. The SFC’s 27 May 2026 circular also permits licensed corporations to serve retail clients through omnibus accounts at a virtual-asset trading platform (VATP) with a professional-investor-only condition, provided the traded assets have passed that VATP’s retail-admission processes. This permits indirect retail access through the licensed corporation; the VATP’s direct retail restriction remains. SFC 26EC26, paragraph 10. The affiliate market-maker framework imposes functional independence, conflicts controls and client priority, with its own notification and professional-review process. SFC 26EC5, paragraphs 15–17; HKMA guidance, page 6; SFC 26EC6 and appendix.
The group should use the existing Singapore and Hong Kong entry-route analysis for the establishment decision, then test the operating book against these additional requirements.
Singapore requires separate analysis of market operation and custody
Singapore’s Payment Services Act requires the relevant licence or exemption for carrying on payment-service business in Singapore. Its digital-payment-token service definitions cover several exchange, arranging, transfer and custody functions. A group must allocate those functions among its entities before assuming that the local customer contract contains the regulated activity. Payment Services Act, section 5 and First Schedule.
The overseas-only business branch is particularly consequential. Financial Services and Markets Act section 137 and the Monetary Authority of Singapore’s (MAS) implementation position apply from 30 June 2025 to the relevant Singapore-connected providers serving overseas customers. MAS states that it will generally not issue licences to those providers. Section 137(5) excludes the specified business regulated or exempt under the Payment Services Act, Securities and Futures Act or Financial Advisers Act; an entity’s actual activities must satisfy the relevant exclusion. FSMA section 137; MAS clarification of 6 June 2025.
Customer-token safeguarding includes trust arrangements, ownership records, permitted pooling and controls over third-party custodians. Regulations 18B–18H contain the operative requirements; their customer-asset definition excludes money, which needs its own safeguarding analysis. MAS guidance additionally addresses foreign-custodian insolvency, custody agreements and operational control. Payment Services Regulations, Division 2A; PS-G03, chapter 3.
Affiliate liquidity also meets concrete conflicts restrictions. MAS’s PS-G03 guidance expects separate legal entities for market operation and broker or agent functions. For the operator’s own-account OTC business on its market, the guidance provides the specified off-market or off-platform back-to-back settlement exception. Related corporations should participate only as brokers or agents and should not conduct own-account OTC business on that market. A viable design must fit those activity boundaries and the provider’s permissions. The group should set inter-entity settlement deadlines through the applicable licence conditions and contracts, separately from custody reconciliation duties. PS-G03, paragraphs 5.4.4–5.4.8.
The EU requires a different design for overseas liquidity
Under MiCA, operating a crypto trading platform, executing orders, receiving and transmitting orders, exchanging as principal and custody are distinct services. An entity’s authorisation or applicable notification route must cover its actual functions. ESMA Q&A 2579 rejects a common order book jointly operated with an overseas platform that lacks MiCA authorisation. The conclusion addresses the foreign co-operator’s role; lawful foreign participation and separately structured execution require their own assessment. MiCA, articles 3 and 59–61; ESMA Q&A 2579, answer of 20 June 2025.
A group can instead assess an EU-operated venue or a properly authorised execution or brokerage model using foreign liquidity. The EU firm must retain substantive decision-making, execution controls and responsibility. MiCA’s exclusion for services provided exclusively within a corporate group has a specific scope; third-party customer service must be classified on its actual structure. MiCA, articles 2(2)(a), 73, 76, 78 and 80; ESMA broker-model opinion, paragraphs 19–40.
Prefunding can determine whether the alternative works. ESMA treats placing customers’ crypto-assets with a third party for future trades as sub-custody: the holder must have the relevant MiCA custody authorisation and customers must be informed. Possession solely to settle a specific already executed transaction falls within a distinct treatment. The group must specify which event causes each transfer and how long assets remain overseas. MiCA, articles 70 and 75(9); ESMA Q&A 2608, answer of 9 July 2025.
MiCA also separates custody liability from prudential resources. Article 75(8) makes the custodian liable for attributable loss, capped at the lost crypto-asset’s market value at the time of loss. Article 67 requires service-dependent prudential safeguards through own funds, insurance or a combination. These provisions leave the group to identify the resources and enforceable debtor for each settlement-failure exposure. MiCA, articles 67 and 75(8).
Execution policy must address the available destinations and applicable customer consent. Affiliate routing needs evidence of execution quality, conflicts management and monitoring. ESMA reads the prohibition on routing-related benefits as covering both reception and transmission and execution. The narrower operational assessment is developed in MiCA best execution using affiliated UAE liquidity. MiCA, articles 72, 78 and 80; ESMA Q&A 2087.
Binding EU rules also require reconstructable records for execution and transmission involving entities outside MiCA’s scope, including the client allocation of aggregated orders. Group conflicts need written controls that address the group’s structure and business activities; disclosure alone cannot replace prevention and management. These requirements should shape the foreign provider’s data and cooperation obligations. Delegated Regulation 2025/1140, articles 11–13; Delegated Regulation 2025/1142, articles 4 and 7.
National property and remedy rules remain relevant. Since 1 July 2026, article L226-2 of France’s Monetary and Financial Code (CMF) links transfer of crypto-asset ownership to entry on the distributed ledger or, for assets held by a MiCA custodian, entry in the client-position register. Article L226-3 protects a good-faith acquirer against a proprietary recovery claim. Mediation by the Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF) has its separate statutory scope. Section 45 of Germany’s Crypto Markets Supervision Act (KMAG) attributes custodial assets, including the client’s omnibus share, to the customer, with an exception for consented disposition for the provider’s or a third party’s account. That exception must also be read with MiCA’s prohibition on own-account use of client crypto-assets. The selected structure needs national title, insolvency and enforcement analysis. French CMF, articles L226-1–L226-3; CMF, article L621-19; KMAG, section 45; MiCA, article 70(1).
The UK global book route is scheduled for 2027
The UK’s 2026 crypto-asset legislation schedules the principal new regime for 25 October 2027. The FCA’s final location guidance contemplates an authorised overseas firm with a UK branch accessing a global trading book, subject to comparable home protections, supervision, cooperation and the firm’s circumstances. The authorisation assessment concerns the overseas legal person and its activities; the branch design needs evidence that the FCA can supervise the business effectively. SI 2026/102, regulation 1; FG26/7.
The future execution rules also constrain the route to that liquidity. For UK retail and elective professional clients, execution and reception-and-transmission firms must ensure execution on a UK qualifying crypto-asset execution venue; other arrangers must take all reasonable steps to secure that outcome. Matched-principal dealing alone does not make a firm such a venue. Within that client scope, principal dealers cannot systematically or predominantly source liquidity from a group platform lacking the required UK authorisation. The relevant client and activity scope must therefore be tested before relying on foreign routing. PS26/11, CRYPTO 5.1.4 and 5.2.1–5.2.7.
The future custody rules permit a tightly bounded settlement float. CASS 17.3.5R(5) caps the relevant float at 2% of the same class of assets remaining in trust for each client, subject to informed consent and the prescribed trading and settlement conditions. Assets in that float sit outside the ordinary trust protections. Customer documents should explain the counterparty claim and insolvency exposure attached to the float. PS26/11, CASS 17.3.5R.
The future Financial Ombudsman route is subject to complainant eligibility, relationship and territorial rules. For the overseas platform operating through a UK establishment, the relevant complainant must have been established or habitually resident in the UK at the time of the acts or omissions. The FCA’s final policy does not extend Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS) compensation to the new crypto activities. These limits affect the customer’s available recourse after a foreign counterparty failure. PS26/13, chapter 12 and DISP 2.6.1R(1)(d).
Until the new regime applies, the existing perimeter, money-laundering registration and financial-promotion rules continue to determine the group’s activity. Security-token or derivative business needs its own analysis. The September 2026 miscellaneous-amendments proposal also requires a final instrument and its commencement before reliance on its proposed exclusions. The group can prepare a 2027 structure while keeping an earlier launch within the existing permissions. MLR 2017, regulation 14A; FCA promotion guidance; draft miscellaneous amendments.
North America combines national and local permission questions
In the United States, identify the instrument, transaction and intermediary functions. The SEC’s March 2026 Commission interpretation explains that a non-security crypto-asset can remain subject to an investment contract in secondary trading while purchasers reasonably expect the issuer’s essential managerial promises to remain connected to it. Asset and transaction classification must therefore be assessed together. SEC Release 33-11412, section IV. Securities exchange and broker requirements, the Commodity Exchange Act’s retail-financing provisions, and money-transmission rules can attach to different aspects of the same customer flow. The Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) distinguishes certain communication or matching services from businesses accepting and transmitting value. Each entity’s actual conduct determines the result. Exchange Act section 5 and section 15; CEA section 2(c)(2)(D); FIN-2019-G001, section 5.1.
State requirements materially affect shared liquidity. New York’s Part 200 prohibits covered business through an unlicensed agent and requires prior written approval for a material business change. The foreign party’s actual agency and operating role therefore matters. 23 NYCRR 200.3(b); DFS review retaining section 200.10. New York’s custody guidance expects preservation of beneficial customer ownership, segregation from proprietary assets and prior approval for material sub-custody changes. Foreign sub-custody requires the Department of Financial Services’ assessment of substantially similar supervision. California’s Digital Financial Assets Law became operative on 1 July 2026, subject to its defined licensing, completed-application and exemption routes. Its custody provisions address same-type asset coverage, customer property and shortfalls, while section 3505 imposes execution duties and six-monthly review. NYDFS guidance of 30 September 2025; California Financial Code sections 3201, 3503 and 3505, as amended by SB 97.
The group should therefore test a resident-facing local platform, its foreign matching operator and each asset holder separately. A customer-ledger entitlement backed by a foreign affiliate receivable needs a specific ownership and insolvency analysis. The proposed federal Regulation Crypto Assets remained a proposal as at 18 November 2026; its contemplated relief cannot be used as an existing launch permission. SEC rulemaking docket S7-2026-27.
Canada offers concrete global-book examples through provincial decisions. Coinbase’s 1 April 2026 decision and Payward’s 1 April 2025 decision describe local customer contracts, global execution and specified custody, conduct and reporting conditions. Their relief has a defined provincial and activity scope. Coinbase’s replacement decision incorporates and varies its earlier conditions, so the two instruments must be read together. Coinbase 2026 and incorporated 2024 decisions; Payward decision.
Those examples also show why settlement terminology matters. Immediate delivery-versus-payment ledger entries can coexist with subsequent daily asset rebalancing between custodians. Canadian perimeter guidance separately tests whether customers actually obtain ownership, possession and control, or continue to hold a claim against the platform. An immediate internal credit can leave the customer still relying on that claim. The group must seek its own applicable registration and relief, with matching custody and customer disclosures. CSA Staff Notice 21-327, pages 2–5; Payward representations 114–116.
Middle East structures require regulator-specific treatment
The United Arab Emirates (UAE) requires separate federal, Dubai Virtual Assets Regulatory Authority (VARA), Abu Dhabi Global Market (ADGM) and Dubai International Financial Centre (DIFC) analyses. Federal Decree-Laws 32 and 33 of 2025 took effect on 1 January 2026, establishing the Capital Market Authority framework while preserving specified earlier instruments. The virtual-asset service provider and alternative trading system (ATS) regulation took effect on 28 February 2026 under its publication clause. The competent authority, regulated activity and territorial targeting must be resolved for each entity. Federal Decree-Law 33, articles 2–3 and 82–85; Resolution 04/Chairman/2026, article 7.
The federal implementing framework provides a licensed virtual-asset multilateral trading facility (MTF) route and prohibits using an organised trading facility (OTF) for virtual-asset trading and settlement. General Article 17 distinguishes multilateral matching that concludes trades from pure order routing. The common engine must fit the relevant activity permission, member eligibility and supervised operating structure. Articles 27–41 require enforceable participant and default rules, approval of rule amendments and qualified custody arrangements; Article 52 provides for virtual-asset settlement through a digital-wallet service provider. VASP Regulation, General Module, article 17, and ATS Module, articles 3, 27–41 and 52.
For an MTF providing custody, ATS Article 64 adds a precise customer remedy: where the licensed entity or its third-party custodian is responsible for an unauthorised or incorrectly executed transfer, the entity must restore the client’s account within three business days and maintain the prescribed compensation arrangements. Group outsourcing preserves the licensed entity’s regulatory responsibility and supervisory access. These requirements must be reflected in the wallet, settlement and service-provider agreements. ATS Module, articles 24 and 64.
In Dubai outside DIFC, VARA separately regulates exchange, broker-dealer and custody services. The exchange’s final-settlement requirement is ordinarily within 24 hours, with the stated exception for matters outside its control. Broker-dealer best-execution responsibility continues when routing. Custody rules restrict asset use and impose their own client-wallet and entity-separation conditions. These requirements should be tested against the actual foreign holding and transfer chain. VARA Exchange Services Rulebook, III.D.1; Broker-Dealer Rulebook, II.A.13; Custody Rulebook, III.A–B.
ADGM distinguishes an intermediary routing orders offshore from an operator conducting substantive multilateral trading-facility activity. The Conduct of Business (COBS) and Market Infrastructure (MIR) rulebooks address market operation, accepted assets, conflicts, custody, remote membership and enforceable default procedures. A foreign participant may need the specific Remote Member route and accompanying recognition conditions. The November 2026 proposal to integrate virtual assets further into the financial-instrument framework was a consultation as at 18 November 2026. ADGM VA Guidance, footnote 24; COBS chapter 17; MIR chapters 2–3 and 8; CP 8 of 2026 announcement.
In DIFC, the Dubai Financial Services Authority (DFSA) framework separately tests token suitability, venue members and settlement arrangements. COB 9.6.11 requires satisfactory clearing and settlement arrangements and the specified regulated or equivalent providers. Its guidance permits the DFSA to consider alternatives where proper central-counterparty clearing is unavailable for reasons beyond the operator’s control: demonstrated instantaneous on-chain finality, or an adequately funded clearing guarantee arrangement with additional capital, stress testing and annual methodology approval. Each requires the DFSA’s case-specific assessment. The rules also impose a qualified restoration duty where the firm is responsible for an unauthorised or incorrectly executed transfer: the outer limit is three business days. That duty must be read with its responsibility trigger and compensation provisions. DFSA COB, sections 9.2–9.6 and 15.4.5; COB 9.6.11 Guidance, paragraphs 2–4.
Bahrain’s category structure reserves public automatic order matching for the relevant exchange permission. CRA 6.3.2 requires clients to prefund their accounts before transacting, and 6.3.3 prohibits financing assistance for their crypto transactions. The ordinary exchange prohibition on own-capital and matched-principal execution also constrains an operator acting as liquidity provider. The Central Bank of Bahrain (CBB) CRA rules restrict outsourcing of core regulated functions and require prior approval for foreign business, including business abroad that is unregulated there. Client-money location, asset custody and settlement obligations remain explicit local constraints. CRA 4.12 requires final settlement by the end of the trading date, preferably intraday or in real time. A foreign matching provider must therefore be assessed against both the exchange permission and outsourcing boundaries. CBB CRA, 1.1.16–16A, 4.12, 6.3, 6.6 and 10.3.12–15.
African comparisons must include the payment and exchange-control legs
In South Africa, the Financial Advisory and Intermediary Services (FAIS) crypto-asset declaration and financial-intelligence requirements govern relevant advice, intermediary services and AML controls. Exchange-control questions remain separate. As at 18 November 2026, the South African Reserve Bank’s (SARB) policy distinguishes an individual’s permitted outward investment arrangements from pooling customer allowances or exporting crypto bought locally. A common customer book cannot assume it may aggregate those flows through a group treasury. The applicable manual and the exact authorised-dealer arrangement must be tested together. FAIS declaration; FIC Directive 9; SARB Authorised Dealer Manual and crypto FAQ.
The 2026 capital-flow and crypto-manual proposals must be distinguished from operative rules. Implementation requires an exchange-control analysis of the actual transfers, including relevant judicial treatment, and the required authorised-dealer or SARB approval or confirmation. Keep the affected cross-border flow disabled until those conditions are resolved. Draft Capital Flow Management Regulations; SARB draft crypto-manual statement.
Nigeria requires a more detailed split. The Nigerian Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) framework governs the relevant trading and investment activities. Its digital asset exchange rules require customer money and crypto before trading, protected client assets and clear, certain intraday settlement; the customer-financing prohibition limits how a liquidity shortfall can be funded. Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) regulations effective 5 November 2026 add activity-specific authorisations for non-security virtual-asset payment uses. Section 4.9 preserves trading-only custody within the SEC branch, while dual activities require the approvals of both authorities. A token’s admission to trading therefore requires a separate assessment when the group uses it for payments or remittances. ISA 2025; SEC Digital Asset Rules, Part E19 and E24–25; CBN Non-Security Virtual Asset Regulations, sections 4 and 9.
For covered cross-border flows, CBN section 11.10 requires approved activity, permissible purposes and eligible counterparties. Using virtual assets to settle, prefund or net foreign obligations arising from foreign-exchange (FX) or remittance transactions requires the specified approved arrangement. Even permitted net settlement must preserve individually identifiable underlying transactions and gross reporting. Section 56.2 preserves existing obligations unless expressly modified by a valid later instrument, so existing bank-account conditions and the new approval must be reconciled for the actual cash and token flows. The 180-day existing-operator transition has registration, reporting, existing-scale and interim-permission conditions. A shared book needs documented SEC, CBN and banking permissions for each applicable function. CBN Regulations, sections 11.10, 54.1 and 56.2.
Brazil and Mexico require different liquidity structures
Brazil’s Resolution BCB 520 regulates intermediaries, custodians, liquidity providers and market makers through distinct provisions. Liquidity-provider contracts must address pricing, transactions and settlement; the liquidity provider is barred from acting as counterparty to other clients or users on the contracting provider’s trading environment, subject to the specified request-for-quote exception. Market makers face separate counterparty and conflicts restrictions. Foreign custody requires the applicable conditions, including regulatory acceptance, enforceability and access. BCB 520, articles 38–39 and 83–84.
The applicable dates matter. Resolution 589 changed article 91’s counterparty restriction to apply from 6 November 2026 and amended its wording. The group must establish the counterparty’s authorisation or a form expressly permitted by Resolution 520, including any valid transitional basis and the particular conditions for overseas services or custody. BCB 520, articles 32–41, 83–84 and 88–91. Under Resolution 277, a specified change of ownership on a book accessed through the provider is excluded from one international-transfer definition. Other FX restrictions, token-pair rules and foreign-supervision assessments continue to apply. The exception should be used only for the transaction it describes. BCB 589, articles 1–2; BCB 277, articles 76-A–76-C.
Mexico first separates banks and financial-technology institutions from non-financial providers. Banxico Circular 4/2019 confines the covered financial institutions’ authorised virtual-asset operations to the prescribed internal use and excludes customer-facing exchange, transmission and custody that expose clients to the relevant risks. A non-financial provider instead needs a separate activity, AML, customer-property and consumer-law assessment. Article 17(XVI) of Mexico’s AML law (LFPIORPI) expressly reaches specified services provided from abroad to Mexican citizens. Circular 4/2019; LFPIORPI, articles 17–18.
Acuerdo 115/2026 generally commences on 30 November 2026, with specified duties phased into 2027 and 2028. A launch after that date must incorporate the applicable new requirements. For a non-financial broker or venue, the contracts must identify agency or principal status, the customer’s asset claim, custody location, failed-settlement remedies and enforceable dispute terms. Mexican AML registration alone leaves those private-law and activity questions to be resolved. Acuerdo 115/2026, transitional provisions; Commercial Code, articles 273–300; Consumer Protection Law, articles 5 and 90.
Oceania separates existing permissions from future platform rules
Australia’s Corporations Act applies according to the product and activity, including the market and financial-services territorial connections. Section 795B(2) provides a conditional Australian licence route for an overseas-authorised financial-product market, requiring sufficiently equivalent home requirements and supervision, cooperation and the other statutory conditions. The Digital Assets Framework Act 2026 schedules its principal reforms for 8 April 2027. Its mandate for future standards expressly accommodates access to foreign liquidity and requires enforceable liquidity-provider or market-maker arrangements with monitoring. The foreign provider’s own licensing analysis remains necessary. New section 912BG gives the platform rules contractual effect between issuer and client, and between clients where they may deal with one another, supporting enforcement of the stated settlement and responsibility terms. Corporations Act, sections 791D–791E, 795B(2) and 911D; Digital Assets Framework Act, commencement table and new sections 912BF–912BG.
The group should map its activity under the law that applies before 8 April 2027 and prepare separately for the new platform and custody obligations. The Australian Securities and Investments Commission’s (ASIC) October 2026 proposed standards are consultation material. An Australian Transaction Reports and Analysis Centre (AUSTRAC) registration or transition position supplies a different regulatory function from financial-services or market permission. ASIC CP 392; AML/CTF Transitional Rules 2026.
New Zealand’s Financial Markets Conduct Act requires a financial-product and market analysis. Where a financial-product market licence is needed, section 317 provides a conditional overseas-market route involving sufficiently equivalent home investor protection and market integrity, information sharing and cooperation. The statutory client-property rules also have a defined financial-advice-product scope. Ordinary spot tokens should not be assigned those protections without satisfying that scope. Financial Service Providers Register (FSPR) registration and dispute-resolution requirements require their own statutory analysis: section 48(3)(b) exempts financial-product market operation from the retail dispute-resolution membership requirement, while additional brokerage or custody services need separate assessment. FMC Act, sections 309–317 and 431W–431ZI; FSPR Act, sections 7A and 48.
New Zealand’s July 2026 AML guidance separately tests each entity and captured activity for a sufficient local connection. Active marketing, repeated customer service, staff and payment infrastructure can matter; online availability alone is insufficient. Market permission requires the separate Financial Markets Conduct Act analysis. DIA territorial guidance, paragraphs 2 and 9–22.
For both jurisdictions, a local broker accessing an overseas market and an entity operating the common matching system are materially different candidates. The group should identify the customer’s enforceable rights and the relevant custody regime before selecting either structure.
Follow customer rights through the whole trade
A common trade lifecycle makes the regional differences usable. Before order entry, identify the owner of the fiat and tokens, the custodian and any permitted use or lien. At order acceptance, identify which entity checks available assets and reserves them. At matching, record the contract formed, its counterparties and whether any novation occurs. At ledger update, identify the entitlement credited and the event that makes it enforceable.
Then analyse inter-entity delivery, return to the permitted custodian and withdrawal availability. Hong Kong’s real-time ledger and subsequent inter-operator settlement illustrate the separation. MiCA article 76(12) requires initiation of final settlement within 24 hours for transactions settled on a distributed ledger, or by the close of the day for off-ledger settlement. The statutory wording must be preserved when setting operational deadlines. SFC conditions 13–27; MiCA article 76(12).
Test failure at each stage. A local operator can owe compensation while its claim against an overseas affiliate remains disputed. Customer property can be segregated operationally yet face a foreign-law dispute over title, tracing, liens or recognition. A contractual netting clause needs the relevant insolvency-law support. These are reasons to identify the governing law, court, recovery mechanism and funded debtor for every customer obligation.
The rulebook should distinguish a rejected order, an erroneous match, a binding unsettled trade, a failed transfer and an insolvency default. For each event, specify suspension powers, notice, valuation time, loss allocation, replacement execution, compensation, recourse and termination. Those are proposed contractual provisions; mandatory regulatory rights and liabilities take priority in the jurisdictions described above.
Build the approval and document package around the selected model
The group should proceed through five decisions.
- Fix the actor and territory map. Identify customer locations and categories, actual operators, executing entities, custodians, banks, tokens and payment uses. Document the licence, exception or approval required for each function.
- Prove overseas eligibility. Obtain licences and conditions, ownership records, supervisory-cooperation evidence and the specific comparability or recognition decision where required. Address onward outsourcing and changes to counterparties.
- Document customer rights and settlement. Align customer agreements, multilateral rules, brokerage terms, custody acknowledgments and default arrangements. Obtain the property, insolvency, netting and enforcement analysis for the actual jurisdictions and asset chain.
- Fund and test the exposure. Set settlement limits, prefunding controls and replenishment triggers. Demonstrate any mandatory reserves, insurance and compensation resources. Test loss and liquidity needs during price moves, bank closure, network interruption and affiliate default.
- Make supervision workable. Provide whole-book surveillance, conflicts controls, execution records, lawful data sharing, regulator access and an orderly exit plan. Secure the required approvals before enabling the relevant customer or asset cohort.
Where joint operation fails the applicable legal test, the group can assess a local book with eligible participants, a genuine agency-routing arrangement or bilateral liquidity. Each alternative changes the actor, custody or credit chain and must be evaluated on that basis. Where a required approval or enforceability conclusion remains unresolved, keep the affected flow outside the launch scope.
Review the liquidity model before launch
Licentium can assess the liquidity model, counterparties, rulebook and settlement responsibilities across the relevant jurisdictions. Contact Licentium.