A business supplies an AI service to enterprise customers and uses third-party models internally. After an inaccurate output causes economic loss, a customer asks for evidence of cover. The business must examine its position as a supplier and as an adopter. A material model change adds questions about declared activities, testing, insurer acceptance and the policy period to which a claim belongs.
The comparison below covers fifteen countries across seven regions. New York supplies the principal US state-law example; Ontario and Quebec show Canadian provincial differences. EU rules sit alongside French and German law. United Arab Emirates (UAE) onshore, Dubai International Financial Centre (DIFC), Abu Dhabi Global Market (ADGM) and Dubai Virtual Assets Regulatory Authority (VARA) have separate roles. The contract issued to the business must be checked against the cited forms.
Start with a loss ledger
Separate customer compensation, the business's own losses, defence expenditure and performance promises. One incident can produce several entries. Each entry needs its own route through the insurance programme.
For the supplier, the first question is whether the policy covers liability arising from the described AI service. For the adopter, the first question is whether a first-party section pays its own loss. An adopter can also incur liability when it uses a model to deliver its services to customers. That activity needs to fall within its insured business description.
- A customer loses money after relying on an inaccurate output. Potential cover and actual clause evidence: Technology errors and omissions (E&O) or professional indemnity (PI). Hiscox UK's Technology clause A.2 expressly addresses specified AI activities, including output reliance and agents. Boundary to test: The claimant, scheduled business, liability, claims trigger and exclusions must fit. Own correction costs and particular contractual remedies have separate restrictions. [P1]
- The adopter loses margin through its own model-assisted decision. Potential cover and actual clause evidence: An express first-party operational-loss or performance section. Chubb Australia's cyber interruption cover requires a defined business-interruption incident. Boundary to test: A wrong decision alone needs another grant. Chubb's incident definition can include human or programming error when the required system disruption or data loss occurs. [P3]
- An output infringes copyright or discloses protected material. Potential cover and actual clause evidence: A specified intellectual property (IP), media or confidentiality grant. Hiscox UK B.1 and Chubb Australia's definition 4.48 provide relevant examples. Boundary to test: Identify the right alleged. Patent, trade-secret and other IP restrictions differ by form. Corporate confidential information can follow a different branch from personal-data liability. [P1] [P3]
- Personal or confidential data is disclosed. Potential cover and actual clause evidence: Cyber security/privacy liability and first-party response expenses; sometimes a technology-liability section. Boundary to test: Identify the data, event and claimant. AIG Singapore's security/privacy section requires its defined event. Its assumed-liability exceptions differ from those in the media section. [P5]
- A service stops working. Potential cover and actual clause evidence: First-party interruption, restoration costs and potentially customer liability for interruption. Boundary to test: Test the cause, affected system, waiting period, outsourced-service terms and the definition of insured interruption. Each section has its own loss calculation. [P3] [P5]
- AI contributes to bodily injury or physical property damage. Potential cover and actual clause evidence: General/public or product liability, or an express extension. Chubb Australia's section 3.1 uses an occurrence-based injury/property grant. Boundary to test: Professional-services, data and product exclusions can change the result. Japan's Sompo scheme uses a separate optional bodily/property cyber endorsement. [P3] [P6]
- The business must defend a customer claim. Potential cover and actual clause evidence: Defence under the relevant liability section. Boundary to test: Check who appoints counsel, consent, allocation between covered and uncovered matters, and whether costs erode the compensation limit. [P1] [P3] [P6]
- The customer seeks a refund, service credit or guaranteed result. Potential cover and actual clause evidence: An express contractual-liability, mitigation or performance provision, if purchased and applicable. Boundary to test: Repair, fee repayment, service-credit and performance exclusions remain decisive. A promise in the customer contract needs to be reconciled with the insurance wording. [P1] [P4] [P6]
For the underlying liability analysis, Software product liability for AI updates and data loss examines when software, updates and damaged data can create product-liability exposure. The insurance inquiry then asks which part of that exposure the purchased contract transfers.
Compare the operative wording
Technology E&O and professional indemnity commonly require a claim arising from defined services. Cyber sections can combine response expenses, interruption and liability for security, privacy or publication events. General/product liability addresses specified injury and property damage. Specialist AI products can target additional performance or operational risks. These categories are a starting point for reading the grants.
The following specimens demonstrate differences that can change a purchasing or claims decision.
- UK: Hiscox Technology, section footer April 2025, in file labelled 0525. What to examine: AI clause A.2; IP B.1; correction, contract and data exclusions; general conditions 11–12. Consequence for the AI business: Express AI cover still requires the scheduled activity and the remaining terms. Overlapping sections and other insurance can restrict recovery to one applicable route. [P1]
- Germany: Hiscox Net IT, October 2025. What to examine: AI activities in I.1; damage-event trigger in IV.1 and V.1; aggregation and non-stacking in IV.4–5. Consequence for the AI business: A claims-made summary would misdescribe this form. Unlimited reporting of covered cases under V.3 still requires an insured damage event. [P2]
- Australia: Chubb PremierTech2, November 2023. What to examine: Technology liability 1.1; cyber 2.1–2.5; public/products 3.1; shared limits in section 6. Consequence for the AI business: One policy contains different triggers and a technology/cyber aggregate. Adding the displayed section limits can overstate available money. [P3]
- New Zealand: QBE ICT0217, copyright 2016. What to examine: Section A civil liability; section B general business liability; definition of Valid Claim and claims condition 7. Consequence for the AI business: The form is ICT0217 with a 2016 copyright footer. The specimen contains a 28-day/30-day post-expiry notice discrepancy requiring written clarification. [P4]
- New Zealand: Delta Technology Liability, April 2023. What to examine: Defence 5.4.2; excess 6.3.4; alteration 6.5. Consequence for the AI business: Compare the right to control defence, costs treatment, excess and material-change conditions against the issued schedule. [P15]
- Singapore: AIG CyberEdge 05-20. What to examine: Security/privacy, media and first-party modules; general condition 7.7. Consequence for the AI business: Pure inaccurate-output loss needs a matching grant. The form makes specified first-party sections primary while other sections have excess/other-insurance treatment. [P5]
- Japan: Sompo chamber scheme for starts from March 2025. What to examine: Optional information technology services endorsement 618 and modification 630. Consequence for the AI business: A first-month restriction can be removed while testing and trial-period restrictions remain. Confirm both endorsement numbers in the issued contract. [P6]
- Brazil: AIG RCP general and special conditions. What to examine: Technology special conditions, pages 57–62; AI services, prohibited practices and economic-loss condition. Consequence for the AI business: The form includes AI services. Page 61 excludes indirect, economic or consequential loss when the insured has not excluded those losses by contract under applicable law. Check the customer clause's legal effectiveness. Check the prohibited practices, warranty exclusion and issued edition. [P7]
- Mexico: Chubb Elite Tecnología, registration shown as 2013. What to examine: Contract liability, guarantee and IP provisions; section 3.29. Consequence for the AI business: The restriction on a third party's copy-protection technology is narrow. It should not be expanded into a universal exclusion for third-party models. [P8]
- South Africa: iTOO-Go Cyber, file labelled 2025, underwritten by Hollard. What to examine: Professional-services and product-failure exclusions 5.8.5–7; defence and US/Canada restrictions. Consequence for the AI business: The supplier needs separate attention to its professional activity. The cyber title alone leaves ordinary service-error liability unresolved. [P9]
- US: Hiscox/Lloyd's portfolio, 07/12. What to examine: Technology I.A; exclusion C on PDF page 27; general III and IV.F. Consequence for the AI business: A written-contract/service-level agreement grant sits alongside an exclusion for defects solely caused by third-party technology. Conditional defence, repayment and written-contract recovery provisions require separate attention. Confirm state-specific terms. [P10]
- France: Hiscox TECH-RCE1115, file version 191218, copyright 2019. What to examine: Contract grant I.I.A; exclusions 6–7 and 19; non-stacking provision, page 23. Consequence for the AI business: Contractual non-performance and specified result obligations can receive cover while contractual penalties and correction costs remain restricted. Compare each promised remedy with its clause. [P11]
- South Africa: iTOO/Hollard Commercial PI, filename May2021v3. What to examine: Clauses 2, 4.5–4.6, 4.12, 6.6–6.7 and optional IP extension 7.1. Consequence for the AI business: The broad computer-error exclusion can leave a gap alongside cyber's professional-services exclusion. Check amendments, scheduled AI services, defence consent and shared limits. [P12]
- Brazil: Chubb Riscos Cibernéticos, version 202601, catalogue from 13 January 2026. What to examine: Clause 5; defence add-on, pages 52–53; alternative professional-services exclusions, pages 90–91. Consequence for the AI business: Defence cover requires the selected add-on. Establish whether a professional-services exclusion is incorporated and which version applies. The alternatives have materially different scope. [P13]
- Mexico: GNP Cyber Safe, 2025 design, registered 12 December 2025. What to examine: DatosSeguros section C; sanctions definition; combined-limit terms. Consequence for the AI business: Data-related defence and sanctions require specific triggers, consent and limits. The lawful-insurability condition requires a legal analysis of the identified sanction. [P14]
The examples compare selected operative clauses.
Munich Re's aiSure material describes AI-specific risk transfer, including operational and performance-related exposures. A purchase decision requires the complete proposed wording: measured performance, baseline, data source, testing, exclusions, loss calculation, payment trigger, territory and claims procedure. The public FAQ and corporate brochure provide product descriptions; the contract must supply these operative terms. [M1]
AI professional liability insurance and AI agent liability insurance are descriptive labels. An agent's delegated authority, tool access and permitted actions must appear accurately in the underwriting record and insured activities.
Align customer promises with the available cover
Customer indemnities can allocate responsibility for specified losses, defence and third-party claims. They can also allocate obligations to preserve evidence, cooperate with investigations and pursue upstream remedies. The insurance contract determines which resulting liabilities the insurer will fund.
Prepare a clause-by-clause alignment record before accepting the customer's insurance requirements:
- Services and permitted use. Match the master services agreement, statement of work and policy description. Identify whether the business provides a model, integration, agent, advice or managed service.
- Indemnity trigger. Separate negligence, breach of contract, IP infringement, confidentiality and security obligations. Identify any promise extending liability beyond the applicable law.
- Remedy. Distinguish damages from refunds, re-performance, model repair, service credits and a guaranteed business result. QBE's New Zealand form and Sompo's Japanese base conditions contain specific guarantee restrictions. [P4] [P6]
- Cap and available money. Compare the contractual cap with the relevant insurance limit, retention, sublimit and aggregate. Include defence erosion and claims already paid. Insurance can be shared across customers and entities.
- Defence and settlement. Reconcile the customer's control rights with the insurer's consent and counsel provisions. An advance payment or settlement can affect recovery.
- Upstream recourse. Record model-provider caps, indemnities, licence restrictions and waivers. Some forms permit defined pre-loss waivers; others require consent for a particular section. Chubb Australia 8.24 treats cyber differently from technology/public-products cover. [P3]
- Evidence and change. Require incident access, model/version records, prompt claim communication and cooperation with underwriting changes. A contractual promise to maintain insurance should identify the necessary evidence and notice rights.
Cap enforceability needs the law governing the relevant obligation. Quebec Civil Code article 1474 restricts exclusions or limits for intentional or gross fault and bodily or moral injury. Saudi Civil Transactions Law article 173 distinguishes contractual non-performance from tort liability and preserves fraud/gross-fault limits. A numerical cap therefore needs a legal classification as well as a commercial calculation. [L-QC] [L-SA-CIVIL]
For South Africa, Kenya, Brazil and Mexico, assess the proposed cap's governing law, terms, party status and the liability being limited. The insurance comparison supplies selected coverage mechanisms.
The AI supplier contracts service describes review of enterprise contract documents and evidence of cover. That work can identify mismatches between customer commitments, upstream terms and the policy documents.
Check who funds and controls the defence
Defence protection can be valuable even when liability is disputed. Its structure changes the usable limit and the insured's immediate cash needs.
- Hiscox UK Technology gives a right, without an obligation, to take control; costs require the relevant conditions. Practical effect: Obtain agreement on counsel and cost allocation. Check the schedule for costs inside or outside the limit. [P1]
- Sompo Japan base article 21 requires written consent and provides no insurer duty to defend. Practical effect: The insured must plan defence management and obtain the required approval. [P6]
- German Insurance Contract Act (VVG) sections 100–101 address justified claims, defence of unjustified claims and costs. Practical effect: Check statutory protection alongside the policy, including the large-risk contractual-freedom rule in section 210. [L-DE]
- Quebec Civil Code article 2503 provides defence-cost protection outside the insurance amount. Practical effect: Decree 656-2022 permits derogation only for defined eligible categories and conditions. Eligibility must be checked at renewal. [L-QC] [L-QC-REG]
- Brazil Law 15.040 article 98(2) requires contracted defence expenses to have a limit distinct from victim compensation. Practical effect: Request the separate defence limit. The provision does not create unlimited defence funding. [L-BR]
- Mexico's Insurance Contract Law article 146 addresses defence expenses subject to contrary agreement. Practical effect: Check whether the issued costs clause varies the statutory default and how its limit operates. [L-MX]
Review coverage and notice duties before a model change
A switch in model provider, greater autonomy, a new customer use, new data, reduced human review or changed testing can alter the insured risk. The significance depends on the question asked, the declared activity, the policy condition and applicable law.
At each release, preserve the old and new service descriptions. Record testing, approval, access rights and changes in foreseeable loss. The person responsible for insurance should compare that record with the proposal and change clauses before deployment.
- US, New York example. Rule that changes the release decision: Insurance Law section 3105 tests material misrepresentation by reference to the insurer's underwriting decision. The actual contract must supply any continuing model-change condition. Section 3420's statutory notice protections have a defined injury/property scope; pure economic E&O claims need separate analysis. [L-NY-3105] [L-NY-3420]
- Canada. Rule that changes the release decision: Quebec article 2466 requires prompt disclosure of changes aggravating risks stipulated in the policy. The changes must result from the insured's acts and be material to premium, risk assessment or continuation of coverage. Ontario requires its own statutory and policy analysis; a Quebec rule cannot be carried into an Ontario policy. [L-QC]
- UK. Rule that changes the release decision: Insurance Act 2015 fair presentation applies before the contract and relevant variations. Hiscox's general condition 3 separately requires notice of material change. Identify the contractual condition governing a mid-term release. [L-UK] [P1]
- France. Rule that changes the release decision: Code des assurances L113-2 requires declaration by registered letter or electronic registered communication within fifteen days of knowledge. The duty concerns changed circumstances that aggravate or create risk and make earlier answers inaccurate or outdated. L113-4 governs the insurer's responses. [L-FR]
- Germany. Rule that changes the release decision: VVG sections 23–27 distinguish voluntary risk increases requiring prior consent from later-known or independent increases. Negligible and agreed-covered increases have exceptions. [L-DE]
- Singapore. Rule that changes the release decision: Read the actual change condition and proposal. The commercial decision in Marketlend left the general continuing-duty question unresolved at paragraph 166. A uniform statutory report-every-update rule should not be assumed. [L-SG-CASE]
- Japan. Rule that changes the release decision: Sompo base article 10 requires notice and an approval request before an attributable change to proposal particulars. Other changes require prompt action after discovery, subject to its exceptions. Insurance Act article 36(4) limits the mandatory protection available for business-loss insurance. [P6] [L-JP]
- UAE onshore. Rule that changes the release decision: The Civil Transactions Code has applied since 1 June 2026. Article 961 requires requested risk information and notice of matters arising during the term that increase the insured risk. [L-AE-CIVIL]
- Saudi Arabia. Rule that changes the release decision: Implementing Regulations articles 53 and 55 address amendment documentation and application information. Obtain the current complete terms and the insurer's issued addendum before relying on an enlarged activity. [L-SA-REG]
- South Africa. Rule that changes the release decision: Section 53 of the Short-term Insurance Act makes materiality relevant to misrepresentation/non-disclosure. The policy's actual continuing-change conditions require separate review. [L-ZA-53]
- Kenya. Rule that changes the release decision: Establish the issued proposal, change clause and claims conditions. The Insurance Act also makes premium receipt important under section 156. [L-KE]
- Brazil. Rule that changes the release decision: Law 15.040 articles 13–16 govern relevant continuing aggravation of risk. Article 16 requires a causal connection for refusal on that basis. Keep the risk-change assessment and claim-causation evidence separately. [L-BR]
- Mexico. Rule that changes the release decision: Insurance Contract Law article 52 requires notice of essential aggravation within twenty-four hours of knowledge. Articles 53–58 supply qualifications and consequences. Build that deadline into the escalation process. [L-MX]
- Australia. Rule that changes the release decision: Chubb condition 8.4 requires notice and written acceptance of materially altered risk. Insurance Contracts Act section 54 can affect reliance on post-contract acts; its operation depends on the act, causation and prejudice. [P3] [L-AU]
- New Zealand. Rule that changes the release decision: Check the current contract and law applicable to its dates. As at 19 November 2026, the Contracts of Insurance Act 2024 was due to start on 15 November 2027. Its disclosure regime does not apply before that date. [L-NZ-FMA]
UK warranty rules also require care. Insurance Act sections 9–11 address basis clauses, suspension following breach and certain risk-reducing terms. Sections 16–17 govern commercial contracting out and transparency. A failed control is therefore analysed through the precise term and statutory test. [L-UK]
Australia's section 54 likewise requires more than reading an exclusion's label. In Maxwell v Highway Hauliers, the High Court examined the post-contract act and statutory consequences. The judgment also distinguishes inherent claims-made time limits. A claim first made outside the required period remains a separate trigger problem. [L-AU-CASE]
Model-change notification decision tree
- Proposed model or service change. Next: compare proposal, insured activities and controls.
- Compare proposal, insured activities and controls. Next: reportable claim, event or circumstance known?
- Reportable claim, event or circumstance known? Yes: notify under each applicable notice clause. No: assess disclosure and change duties.
- Notify under each applicable notice clause. Next: assess disclosure and change duties.
- Assess disclosure and change duties. Next: required notice or approval process?
- Required notice or approval process? Yes: give notice or request approval as required. Unclear: resolve the applicable requirement in writing. No: record the assessment and applicable terms.
- Give notice or request approval as required. Next: requirements resolved and any required acceptance obtained?
- Resolve the applicable requirement in writing. Next: requirements resolved and any required acceptance obtained?
- Requirements resolved and any required acceptance obtained? No or refused: keep current activity; obtain terms or revise change. Yes: testing and other deployment conditions met?
- Keep current activity; obtain terms or revise change. Next: assess disclosure and change duties.
- Record the assessment and applicable terms. Next: testing and other deployment conditions met?
- Testing and other deployment conditions met? No: complete required controls or revise the change. Yes: record effective terms and any required acceptance.
- Complete required controls or revise the change. Next: assess disclosure and change duties.
- Record effective terms and any required acceptance. Next: deploy within insured activities and retain evidence.
The two notifications serve different purposes. A change notice reports an altered exposure under the applicable duty. The terms determine whether an approval request, consent or endorsement is also required. A claim or circumstance notice seeks protection under the relevant policy period. Complete either process when its trigger occurs; neither should wait for the other.
Preserve four dates around the change
Record the output or act, awareness of a possible claim, the customer's first demand and notification to the insurer. Add the model deployment date alongside them. An error before the update can produce a claim afterwards. A prior circumstance notice can connect that claim to an earlier policy, subject to its particulars and deeming clause.
Related-claims terms can combine losses across customers or policy periods. Hiscox UK's same-source wording and Chubb Australia's Single Claim definition illustrate this issue. A different version number alone does not establish a new limit. The causal connection and the actual aggregation wording must be analysed. [P1] [P3]
Expiry deserves a separate review. QBE's New Zealand specimen defines Valid Claim using a twenty-eight-day reporting period, while claims condition 7 refers to thirty days. Obtain written clarification and use prompt in-period notice while that discrepancy remains unresolved. [P4]
Mexico's article 145 Bis permits two liability structures. One covers events during the policy or the preceding year, with the first written claim to the insured or insurer during the policy. The other covers events during the policy, with the first written claim during it or the following year. Other temporal limitations are inadmissible, although these periods may be extended. Match the issued trigger to the applicable alternative before replacing a policy or buying an extended reporting period. Observe the separate notification duties. [L-MX]
Check entities, territory, courts and lawful placement separately
List every legal entity supplying the service, operating the model, employing staff and receiving customer claims. Then map the risk location, covered territory, claimant forum, policy law and insurer's placement authority. A subsidiary definition can contain acquisition, revenue, geography or retroactive-date conditions.
A global master and local policies need a written interaction map. Identify which insurer receives notice, controls defence and pays the local insured. Compare deductibles, local limits, difference-in-conditions or difference-in-limits provisions, aggregate erosion and recovery rights. Any financial-interest clause needs its own insured-loss and payment analysis.
- North America. Placement point that affects the programme: New York has a regulated excess-lines route under section 2118. In Canada, the insurance-in-Canada analysis of the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (OSFI) concerns the insurer's activities, while provincial requirements remain relevant. Guidance from the Registered Insurance Brokers of Ontario (RIBO) addresses consent and comparable-cover conditions for unlicensed insurers. [L-NY-2118] [L-CA-OSFI] [L-ON-RIBO]
- Europe. Placement point that affects the programme: An eligible EU insurer's authorisation and passport operate within the applicable regulatory framework. France and Germany also require analysis under their national rules. A UK policy's worldwide wording needs a separate lawful-placement analysis for each foreign risk. [L-EU] [L-DE-VAG]
- Asia. Placement point that affects the programme: Singapore's broker rules distinguish licensed insurers, prescribed routes and specific permission from the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS). Japan generally restricts unlicensed foreign insurance over specified Japanese residents/property, with product exceptions and a prior-permission route. The relevant applicant must satisfy the actual exception before relying on an offshore policy. [L-SG-MAS] [L-JP-FSA]
- UAE. Placement point that affects the programme: Federal Decree-Law 6/2025 article 82 restricts onshore property/liability placement with foreign or financial-free-zone insurers, subject to specified exceptions. DIFC COB 7.2.2 has its own actor and financial-free-zone distinctions. ADGM's amended rules require a separate analysis. [L-AE] [L-DIFC] [L-ADGM]
- Saudi Arabia. Placement point that affects the programme: Implementing Regulations article 14 contains a prior written permission route for specified dealings with foreign providers where local cover is unavailable. Insurer and intermediary licences and approved product documents are needed for the intended placement. [L-SA-REG] [L-SA-IA]
- Africa. Placement point that affects the programme: South Africa's Insurance Act section 5 regulates insurance business, including specified foreign-insurer activity through local actors. Kenya section 20 requires prior written approval for its foreign-placement route. Section 20(5) preserves contract validity despite a contravention, while regulatory consequences remain. [L-ZA] [L-KE]
- Latin America. Placement point that affects the programme: Brazil's Complementary Law 126 (LC126) and foreign-placement rules provide defined exceptions to local placement, including documented unavailability. Mexico's Insurance and Surety Institutions Law (LISF) restricts foreign insurance of specified Mexican risks and contains an exceptional authorisation route. Article 24 denies legal effect to contracts contrary to articles 20–21, while preserving specified premium-refund and good-faith-party rights. [L-BR-PLACEMENT] [L-MX-LISF]
- Oceania. Placement point that affects the programme: Australia's Insurance Regulations 2024 contain specified exceptions for unauthorised foreign insurers, including qualifying high-value and broker-certified risks. Ordinary AI exposure does not itself establish an exception. New Zealand's insurer-licensing test concerns carrying on insurance business in New Zealand; a planned transaction still needs its own route checked. [L-AU-REG] [L-NZ-RBNZ]
Brazilian renewals also cross a regulatory transition. The announcement of CNSP 496/2026 by the Superintendence of Private Insurance (SUSEP) gives 4 January 2027 as the deadline for existing plans to adapt. It states that the new requirements become mandatory for contracts formed or renewed from 5 January 2027, with an earlier adapted-plan route. SUSEP separately gives 2 January 2027 as CNSP 494/2026's commencement. Obtain the insurer's plan and wording version, then apply the transition to the intended inception or renewal date. Law 15.040 is already operative. [L-BR-496] [L-BR-494]
Dubai VARA's Company Rulebook VI.D requires specified insurance for licensed virtual-asset service providers (VASPs). A group policy must explicitly identify the VASP and its applicable cover. The business first needs to establish whether it conducts the regulated activity. Supplying or using AI alone is insufficient to apply that licence requirement. [L-VARA]
A performance-trigger product can also introduce questions about distribution and trigger authority. Parametric insurance from a Kenyan trigger engine for UK commercial cover addresses those roles where a business operates a trigger service.
Treat fines and penalties as a separate legal review
A policy's phrase “where legally insurable” requires a second inquiry into the identified sanction. Record the imposing authority, offence, person liable, governing law and location of enforcement. Separate the fine itself from investigation costs, defence and compensatory claims.
- New York: Department of Financial Services (NYDFS) Circular Letter 6 of 1994. Limit relevant to the insurance decision: The regulator states that punitive-damages insurance is contrary to New York public policy. Award type and governing-law questions still require analysis. [L-NY-FINES]
- UK: FCA GEN 6.1. Limit relevant to the insurance decision: The specified prohibition concerns FCA financial penalties. Defence costs and penalties imposed by other bodies require their own treatment. [L-UK-FCA]
- France: Prudential Supervision and Resolution Authority (ACPR) statement, updated September 2026. Limit relevant to the insurance decision: ACPR regards reimbursement of administrative monetary sanctions as contrary to public policy, subject to the courts' assessment. This is a supervisory position. [L-FR-FINES]
- Brazil: Law 15.040 article 10. Limit relevant to the insurance decision: The prohibition covers fines and penalties arising from criminal offences personally committed by the insured. It should not be expanded into a rule deciding every administrative sanction. [L-BR]
- Australia: Commonwealth Work Health and Safety (WHS) Act section 272A. Limit relevant to the insurance decision: Insurance and indemnification for specified penalties are prohibited, subject to the section's terms. The Commonwealth Act's application is limited; state and territory regimes require separate analysis. [L-AU-WHS]
- New Zealand: Health and Safety at Work Act section 29. Limit relevant to the insurance decision: The section invalidates prohibited fine/infringement-fee insurance and creates an offence. Defence and reparation require separate classification. [L-NZ-HSWA]
For Canada, Germany, Singapore, Japan, the UAE, Saudi Arabia, South Africa, Kenya and Mexico, a commitment to fund a particular fine requires a sanction-specific legal conclusion. Some policies already exclude fines contractually, including the Japanese Sompo base wording. Others use a legal-insurability condition. Both the law and the operative grant must permit payment. [P2] [P5] [P6]
Request a usable evidence pack
At renewal, the insurance owner should collect the complete contractual set and ask the licensed intermediary or insurer to reconcile it with the AI exposure.
- Issued policy, schedule, endorsements and wording identifier. Question it must answer: Which sections, limits, entities, services, dates, territory and courts were actually agreed?
- Proposal, attachments, presentations and renewal declarations. Question it must answer: What did the business represent about model use, autonomy, data, testing, oversight and claims history?
- Customer and model-provider contracts. Question it must answer: Which indemnities, guarantees, caps, defence rights and recourse restrictions exist?
- Model inventory and change log. Question it must answer: Which versions and activities existed at placement, at the error and at the claim?
- Change assessment, required notices and any required acceptance or endorsement. Question it must answer: What was required, who received or accepted it, and which terms and effective date apply?
- Loss-to-clause response. Question it must answer: Which clause addresses inaccurate outputs, IP, confidentiality, interruption and first-party loss, and which exclusions remain?
- Limit and other-insurance chart. Question it must answer: How do defence, related claims, local/master policies and shared aggregates affect available funds?
- Placement record. Question it must answer: Which licences, exemptions, approvals and local policies support the intended risk locations?
- Claims instructions and notice addresses. Question it must answer: Who must receive which notice, by what deadline, and what constitutes receipt?
- Insurer's premium receipt and inception confirmation. Question it must answer: Has cover attached? Kenya Insurance Act section 156 requires insurer receipt before assumption of the Kenyan risk. Reconcile any broker payment record with that rule. [L-KE]
- Certificate plus requested endorsements. Question it must answer: Which facts does the certificate evidence, and where are the actual insured status and notice rights created?
Respect confidentiality terms when sharing insurance documents. For example, Chubb Australia's condition 8.10 contains restrictions and specified exceptions. Where necessary, obtain consent or provide an authorised extract alongside the certificate. [P3]
New York Insurance Law section 502 prevents certificates from enlarging policy cover or creating additional policy rights. Texas also regulates certificate representations under Insurance Code chapter 1811. Elsewhere, examine the certificate's actual wording and legal effect. A request for AI liability coverage should be answered with the relevant policy evidence and the conditions attached to it. [L-NY-CERT] [L-TX-CERT]
When a demand arrives
- Preserve the demand, inputs, outputs, model version, access permissions, test evidence and human decisions. Record who knew what and when.
- Notify every potentially responsive policy using its contractual address and required particulars. Keep delivery evidence and acknowledgements.
- Identify any earlier circumstance notice, related incident or policy period. Check retroactive dates and aggregation before allocating the claim.
- Request consent for counsel, specialists, mitigation and settlement where required. Preserve necessary immediate protective action and the basis for it.
- Maintain separate ledgers for customer damages, defence, correction, restoration, interruption and contractual credits. Give the insurer the causal evidence for each.
- Preserve upstream claims and limitation dates. Coordinate local and master insurers before admissions, releases or a global settlement.
Separate legal review from regulated insurance advice
Legal policy review can explain the contract, applicable law and customer commitments. Recommending or arranging a specific product can engage insurance regulation. England and Wales' Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) guidance, France's distribution definition, UAE insurance-consultancy rules and Saudi Insurance Authority (IA) licensing categories illustrate the need to identify the actual activity and any valid professional exception. An engagement should allocate placement and regulated recommendations to appropriately authorised participants. [L-SRA] [L-FR-DIST] [L-AE] [L-SA-IA]
In South Africa, test recommendations and intermediation against sections 1 and 7 of the Financial Advisory and Intermediary Services Act (FAIS). Brazil's Law 4.594 articles 1–2 include insurance-type and insurer recommendations in brokerage. Mexico's LISF articles 91 and 93 regulate the specified insurance-agent advice and authorisation. Kenya combines Insurance Act section 150 with the 2025 Insurance Professionals Act. Its section 20 includes insurance consulting, and section 41 contains a practising-certificate transition. Confirm authorisation before assigning those services. [L-ZA-FAIS] [L-BR-BROKER] [L-MX-LISF] [L-KE-PROF]
Three coverage outcomes
1. A supplier faces a customer claim over inaccurate output
If the issued contract uses the Hiscox UK Technology wording, clause A.2 provides a route for defined AI liability. The supplier's service and the claims and territory conditions must fit the contract. The business must still establish liability and address the applicable exclusions.
For an output before the model change, record the error, awareness, demand and insurer notice. A later demand may engage a properly notified earlier circumstance. For an output after the change, check the altered business description and general condition 3 notice. A cost of correcting the model or a contractual service credit requires its own analysis. The affirmative AI clause cannot resolve those separate entries in the loss ledger. [P1]
2. An adopter loses money after relying on a model
If the business's policy uses the Australian PremierTech2 wording, the following trigger distinction matters. The adopter's lost margin follows a wrong business decision, with no established system disruption, data loss or other defined interruption incident. The cyber interruption section lacks an established trigger on those facts.
If the evidence instead establishes the required incident, including qualifying human or programming error, section 2.2 requires further examination. A claim the adopter brings against its model provider follows the provider contract and any applicable liability cover. An express first-party performance grant would be needed for an otherwise uncovered performance loss. [P3]
3. A modified service causes a loss soon after release
For a Japanese supplier whose policy includes Sompo endorsement 618, article 3 restricts certain defects in new or modified services, including testing omissions, trial-period incidents and the customer's first month of formal use.
Adding endorsement 630 removes the specified first-month restriction. The testing and trial restrictions remain. The supplier therefore needs the correct endorsement, ordinarily required tests, deployment records and the required notice and approval request for changed proposal particulars. The customer start date and the actual cause of the loss decide which branch applies. [P6]
Review the policy set before a coverage commitment
Bring the issued policy set, proposal, customer contract, upstream terms and dated model-change record to a scoped legal review. Those documents allow the reviewer to identify the relevant grant, the remaining condition or exclusion, and the contractual change needed before the business gives a coverage commitment.
Sources and versions
The sources below identify the authorities and specimens used for the comparison. Policy section and article references appear beside the relevant propositions.
- [P1] Hiscox UK Technology: section 04/25, file 0525; general terms 10/22.
- [P2] Hiscox Germany Net IT, October 2025.
- [P3] Chubb Australia PremierTech2, 11/2023.
- [P4] QBE New Zealand ICT0217; copyright 2016.
- [P5] AIG Singapore CyberEdge, 05-20.
- [P6] Sompo Japan chamber scheme, March 2025 starts; endorsements 618 and 630.
- [P7] AIG Brazil RCP; technology special conditions pp57–62.
- [P8] Chubb Mexico Elite Tecnología; registration 2013.
- [P9] iTOO-Go Cyber, filename 2025; Hollard underwriter.
- [P10] US-hosted Hiscox/Lloyd's portfolio 10401 07/12.
- [P11] France Hiscox TECH-RCE1115; filename DEC2018/Version191218; copyright 2019.
- [P12] iTOO/Hollard Commercial PI; filename May2021v3, metadata 31 January 2024.
- [P13] Chubb Brazil Riscos Cibernéticos, version 202601, catalogue from 13 January 2026.
- [P14] GNP Cyber Safe 2025; registration 12 December 2025.
- [P15] Delta NZ Technology Liability, Tech03-15 R0423, April 2023.
- [M1] Munich Re aiSure FAQ; product description.
- [L-QC] Quebec Civil Code, official consolidation 9 September 2026.
- [L-SA-CIVIL] Saudi Civil Transactions Law, article 173; official indexed native provision.
- [L-DE] German Insurance Contract Act, VVG.
- [L-QC-REG] Quebec decree 656-2022, eligibility for defence-cost derogation.
- [L-BR] Brazil Law 15.040/2024, effective 11 December 2025.
- [L-MX] Mexico Insurance Contract Law.
- [L-NY-3105] New York Insurance Law section 3105.
- [L-NY-3420] New York Insurance Law section 3420.
- [L-UK] UK Insurance Act 2015.
- [L-FR] French Code des assurances L113-1 to L113-17.
- [L-SG-CASE] Marketlend v QBE [2025] SGHC(I) 1, paragraphs 165–176.
- [L-JP] Japan Insurance Act, especially articles 4, 29, 31 and 36(4).
- [L-AE-CIVIL] UAE Civil Transactions Code 25/2025, Arabic government source, articles 953–966.
- [L-SA-REG] Saudi insurance Implementing Regulations; official indexed provisions.
- [L-ZA-53] South Africa Insurance Amendment Act 17/2003, amending STIA section 53.
- [L-KE] Kenya Insurance Act, regulator-hosted 2023 consolidation.
- [L-AU] Australia Insurance Contracts Act 1984, compilation of 8 October 2026.
- [L-NZ-FMA] FMA, updated 29 October 2026; commencement 15 November 2027.
- [L-AU-CASE] Maxwell v Highway Hauliers [2014] HCA 33, paragraphs 19–27.
- [L-NY-2118] New York Insurance Law section 2118.
- [L-CA-OSFI] OSFI, Insurance in Canada of Risks.
- [L-ON-RIBO] RIBO guidance, unlicensed insurers.
- [L-EU] EIOPA reproduction of Solvency II article 15.
- [L-DE-VAG] Germany VAG section 67; see also sections 8 and 61.
- [L-SG-MAS] MAS broker toolkit, version 3.4 issued 12 November 2025, pp7 and 16.
- [L-JP-FSA] Japan FSA, foreign insurance notice of 17 October 2024.
- [L-AE] UAE DFL6/2025, especially articles 2, 60–62, 82 and 185.
- [L-DIFC] DIFC DFSA COB7.2.2.
- [L-ADGM] ADGM insurance amendments effective 27 April 2026.
- [L-SA-IA] Saudi Insurance Authority licensing categories.
- [L-ZA] South Africa Insurance Act 18/2017, section 5.
- [L-BR-PLACEMENT] Brazil LC126/2007, articles 19–20; procedure in CNSP451/2022 and SUSEP683/2022.
- [L-MX-LISF] Mexico LISF, reform 14 November 2025, articles 19–24.
- [L-AU-REG] Australia Insurance Regulations 2024, compilation of 13 December 2025, sections 5–12.
- [L-NZ-RBNZ] RBNZ explanation of carrying on insurance business; updated 17 August 2026.
- [L-BR-496] SUSEP announcement of CNSP 496/2026.
- [L-BR-494] SUSEP announcement: CNSP 494/2026 commences 2 January 2027.
- [L-VARA] VARA Company Rulebook VI.D, version 19 May 2025.
- [L-NY-FINES] NYDFS Circular Letter 6 (1994).
- [L-UK-FCA] FCA GEN6.1, including 6.1.5 and 6.1.7.
- [L-FR-FINES] ACPR administrative-sanctions statement, updated 24 September 2026.
- [L-AU-WHS] Commonwealth WHS Act, sections 12 and 272A.
- [L-NZ-HSWA] New Zealand HSWA section 29.
- [L-NY-CERT] New York Insurance Law section 502.
- [L-TX-CERT] Texas Insurance Code chapter 1811.
- [L-SRA] SRA guidance for insurance distribution by law firms.
- [L-FR-DIST] France Code des assurances L511-1.
- [L-ZA-FAIS] South Africa FAIS 37/2002 ss1,7.
- [L-BR-BROKER] Brazil Law 4.594/1964, official text, arts1–2,18.
- [L-KE-PROF] Kenya Insurance Professionals Act 5/2025, ss20–24,41.